Back-splash Choice Assistance

I need help choosing which tiles to use for my kitchen back-splash. I have narrowed down six choices to two already but I'm struggling to make the final call. Can my loyal readers please vote in the comments? So far, each time I've asked a couple of people for their views it has come back as a draw. In fact the running tally is eleven left and twelve right. I hope the internet can help figure this out for me.